Phillies Add Josh Harrison To Replenish a Depleted Bench

Again on January 5, Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski instructed members of the media that he was largely completed making strikes. Two days later, he finalized a deal for Tigers nearer Gregory Soto. On January 19, Dombrowski made an identical assertion, claiming he wasn’t planning so as to add any extra gamers forward of spring coaching. Earlier than the month was up, he flipped the change once more, signing infielder Josh Harrison to a one-year, $2 million contract. That is the newest instance of what’s changing into a pattern for Dombrowski: stunning the Philadelphia devoted with higher gamers and greater budgets than they have been anticipating.

A celebration pooper may inform you that signing Harrison isn’t on the identical stage as Dombrowski’s large shock from final winter, when he inked Nick Castellanos and pushed the Phillies’ payroll over the luxurious tax for the very first time. Then once more, a good larger social gathering pooper may reply by mentioning that Harrison was value 2.1 extra WAR than Castellanos final season. The primary social gathering pooper may reply by citing Harrison’s mediocre Steamer projections for the upcoming 12 months; the largest social gathering pooper of all would chime in to remind you that no quantity of shock free-agent signings will cancel scholar debt or decelerate rising sea ranges or make Dick Monfort cease speaking. However I’m getting off matter now.

Signing Harrison isn’t a season-altering transfer, nevertheless it’s additional proof the Phillies are keen to spend the required {dollars} to maintain up within the NL East. A extra optimistic fan may additionally see the symbolism of this signing, as Dombrowski continues to proper the wrongs of the earlier entrance workplace regime. The Phillies first signed Harrison to a minor league deal again in November 2019 however in the end selected Neil Walker as their utility infielder as a substitute. Harrison ended up enjoying 33 video games for the Nationals that season with a 108 wRC+; Walker, alternatively, performed simply 18 video games in Philadelphia, posting a dismal 43 wRC+, getting DFA’d in September, and retiring not lengthy after. The Phillies missed the postseason by one measly sport that 12 months, and it’s laborious to not surprise if maintaining the correct infielder would have made all of the distinction. Signing Harrison in 2023 doesn’t get the Phillies to the playoffs in 2020, nevertheless it closes the door on a irritating entrance workplace determination from some of the irritating seasons in latest reminiscence. However once more, I digress.

Harrison isn’t a serious signing for the Phillies, and his wage is a drop within the bucket for a workforce that’s spent $399 million on free brokers this winter. Even so, this acquisition comes as a nice shock for followers who have been ready to see Kody Clemens make the Opening Day roster. Philadelphia gave up two invaluable bench bats within the Soto commerce: Matt Vierling, an amazing line-drive hitter in opposition to left-handed pitching, and Nick Maton, a flexible infield defender. Harrison is each of these issues, and he’ll assist fill the holes these two left behind. Anticipate him to take a 26-man roster spot from Clemens and to be the primary man that Rob Thomson calls on when he wants a righty pinch-hitter. Harrison will share utility duties with Edmundo Sosa, giving the Phillies two strong backups ought to any of their beginning infielders miss important time.

Harrison spent the 2022 season with the White Sox, for whom he slashed .256/.317/.370 and hit seven residence runs in 119 video games. The veteran complemented his common bat with strong protection and invaluable versatility, enjoying 90 video games at second and one other 23 at third, and placing up 6 DRS and 4 OAA. He additionally crammed in briefly at shortstop and in left subject. Harrison received’t be getting common reps at both of these positions, however he can cowl in a pinch. His outfield skills are significantly related for the Phillies, who solely have room for one true outfielder on their bench. Harrison could get the occasional begin in an outfield nook when Castellanos or Kyle Schwarber wants a time without work.

Whereas his glove stays an asset, Harrison’s bat took a step backward final 12 months. After two straight seasons with a wRC+ over 100, his efficiency dipped under league common in 2022:

There’s nothing significantly worrying right here. Harrison’s strikeout charge went up, nevertheless it’s nonetheless wonderful in comparison with league common. In the meantime, his energy numbers dropped, however so did league-wide energy; his ISO fell by seven ticks, however his ISO+ rose by 5. Total, he was much less productive on the plate in 2022 than he was the 12 months prior, however that’s to be anticipated for a 12-year veteran in his age-34 season.

If there’s a trigger for concern, it lies beneath the floor — particularly, within the batted ball knowledge. When Harrison succeeds, he does so by making loads of contact and hitting numerous line drives:

The league-average contact charge lately is about 76%, and the league-average line drive charge sits round 20–21%. Thus, the common hitter would have recorded about 89 line drives in the identical variety of plate appearances as Harrison from 2020 to ’21; he hit 120. That’s how he remained a productive hitter regardless of his mediocre plate self-discipline and restricted energy. Sadly, in 2022, his line drive charge plummeted; he was nonetheless making a ton of contact, however extra of his batted balls have been going into the bottom:

Merely put, this isn’t good. All else being equal, a line drive is nearly 3 times extra probably than a floor ball to end in a success. With no excessive line drive charge, Harrison received’t be capable of preserve a excessive BABIP, like he has for many of his profession, and his efficiency will endure. One season continues to be a small pattern in relation to line drive charge, so there’s no want for outright panic simply but, however Harrison’s line drive charge is one thing to regulate, particularly as a result of this wasn’t the one noticeable change in his batted ball profile. As well as, a surprisingly excessive variety of his balls within the air went to the other subject:

This isn’t essentially a nasty factor — Harrison doesn’t hit for a lot energy, so he may profit from spraying the ball to all sides — however such a sudden and dramatic shift in batted ball course may very well be the signal of an issue, particularly when mixed with a steep drop-off in line drive charge. Certainly, this may be an early indication that Harrison’s capacity to establish pitches and time pitchers is on the decline. In additional help of that principle, he swung at extra pitches exterior the zone and fewer pitches inside it this previous season, and when he chased, he was extra more likely to miss. His strikeout charge bore the implications.

Bearing the warning indicators in thoughts, Harrison could also be in for additional offensive decline in 2023, however there’s no disgrace in that. The final time he signed with the Phillies, it appeared like his profession may be nearing an finish. He was coming off a 12 months with a 22 wRC+ and -0.9 WAR, and he was left off the roster days earlier than the season started. Since then, he’s performed three extra seasons, earned one other $9 million, and formally reached 10 years of massive league service time. He has put collectively a formidable profession, and there’s nothing improper with settling right into a bench function in his twilight years.

If re-signing Harrison symbolizes how far the Phillies have come, so too does re-signing with the Phillies signify all the pieces that he has achieved. Not so way back, he was reduce by a workforce that completed 4 video games under .500. A couple of years later, the defending Nationwide League champions are welcoming him again with open arms.