Is Erik ten Hag ever going to learn from his mistakes? – Man United News And Transfer News

1

In keeping with The Athletic’s Mark Critchley, regardless of Manchester United’s 2-1 defeat by the hands of Brighton yesterday, “there may be some small progress” on the membership.

It’s true that however for an unlucky accident when an offside Josh Zirkzee’s knee touched Alejandro Garnacho’s goal-bound shot on the objective line, United may nicely have received the tie and gone into the grudge match with Liverpool subsequent week with six factors below their belt.

That little bit of dangerous luck is compounded by teething troubles, Critchley notes. He factors out that whereas the defending on Brighton’s harm time winner regarded terrible, “Of the 9 United gamers within the penalty space as Adingra performed his cross, three had been new signings, two joined simply final week and 4 had not began the sport.

“The routines themselves had been being orchestrated by a set-piece coach in Andreas Georgson who has a superb popularity but solely arrived lower than a month in the past.”

That’s all very nicely, and it’s actually additionally true that United are taking part in a extra enticing and managed model of soccer than they did final season. It was a loss, however at the very least one which was typically extra pleasing on the attention.

However you would additionally have a look at this one other manner. Had the Zirknee not touched Garnacho’s shot, and had Antony and Mazraoui proven Adingra to the surface, or had Diogo Dalot, Lisandro Martinez and Alejandro Garnacho been marking the military of Brighton gamers queueing up on the again submit, then United could have received and that victory would have been papering over the cracks that also exist all through the group.

Many people gave supervisor Erik ten Hag the advantage of the doubt for a lot of final season as a result of horrific harm disaster he endured and the comparatively weak squad he had at his disposal – though weaker squads, on paper at the very least, completed increased than United within the desk.

However ought to Ten Hag be given credit score for what goes higher for United and may he not be held accountable for what continues to be going badly?

First, there may be the change in system from the ugly transitions-based soccer the Dutchman preached. This variation began in the previous few video games of final season. Did Ten Hag lastly see the sunshine and abandon the flawed technique, or did he obtain orders from the newly appointed technical director, Jason Wilcox, to make the change? That was the hearsay and the timing actually provides you pause.

Second, United struggled to search out the again of the online towards Fulham with Bruno Fernandes within the false 9 position and Mason Mount behind. Some huge cash was spent on Serie A sensation Zirkzee in July, so why did Ten Hag stick with the zero striker experiment?

At half time, once more he appeared to see the sunshine and made the change, changing Mount with the Dutchman. However he himself took away the credit score we would have given him for the courageous(-ish) change when he mentioned after the sport that Mount had been subbed because of an harm.

In different phrases, by his personal admission, we will’t give Ten Hag the credit score for correcting issues tactically at half time, the change was enforced.

The objective that by no means was would have been scored by Alejandro Garnacho, however he didn’t begin the sport. He got here on as sub within the Group Protect and towards Fulham and regarded palms down United’s most in-form winger on each events. But Ten Hag retains beginning Marcus Rashford, as he did nearly incessantly final season, when the England man continues to disappoint, fluff his pictures, and exhibit terrible physique language when issues don’t go his manner.

Everyone knows what Rashford is able to and all of us need him to be given ample alternative to re-find his type, however, as famous right here yesterday, not on the expense of dropping or failing to win match after match whereas he battles his inside demons.

The system is easy. Begin your type wingers, get the sport received, then convey on the struggler towards drained legs to assist him get his mojo again.

No-one would defend Jadon Sancho’s petulance in his ongoing spat with Ten Hag, however his unique gripe does appear legitimate: some gamers do appear to get preferential therapy, whereas others appear to have to do all the things these ones do backwards and in excessive heels, to cite Lauren Bacall.

And whereas we’re with regards to the spat with Sancho, Ineos should be pulling their hair out over that scenario.

Once more, stressing that no person is supporting or condonining the unprofessional and infantile Sancho, the details nonetheless stay that Ten Hag has utterly mishandled the scenario from begin to end and, in dropping Sancho after he carried out nicely in pre-season and happy the coaches, has proven himself to be petulant and vindictive himself.

And if, as some followers suspect, there was by no means actually a rapprochement and taking part in Sancho in pre-season was placing him within the store window for a switch, then that has backfired badly.

However again to techniques, and it’s nonetheless removed from clear what United’s persona is. Ineos appear to be backing Ten Hag within the switch market – or else, agree with him – in pursuing one other holding midfielder in Manuel Ugarte. However the place is the creativity in midfield? Ought to there not be at the very least one central midfielder whose power is his passing?

The one visionary passers of the ball within the United squad are Bruno Fernandes and Christian Eriksen. The latter can’t get a sport for love nor cash, whereas the previous is continually being performed out of place by Ten Hag, on the wing or up high, the place his abilities are wasted.

Even then, Fernandes’ warmth map from yesterday’s sport reveals neither a false 9 nor a quantity 10. It’s extra just like the heatmap of a left again. It’s exhausting to justify these techniques when Garnacho and Zirkzee sat on the bench for a lot of the sport.

Supply: sofascore.com

Hopefully, Mr Critchley is correct and these are all simply teething issues. All of us need to imagine Ineos had been smart in maintaining Ten Hag and that he, they usually, all know what they’re doing. We’ll discover out quickly sufficient.

Play free of charge to win the brand new United package! We’re awarding a brand new prize each PL matchweek, courtesy of Goat Kits! To play, simply (1) Be part of this week’s model new PL Problem league right here with our league code puu1tk and enter this week’s competitors. (2) Observe The Peoples Individual on X and reply the tie breaker query. Full directions and guidelines right here.
You can too go to Goat Kits at goatkitstore.com and use low cost code TPP30 to get 30% off your first buy!