Each Thursday right here at FightHype, boxing followers collect round my bulbous, bulging sack in anticipation of an Ol’ Trustworthy cash shot of gooey, salty reality. This Thursday is not any completely different. So, put your goggles on and cinch up your plastic poncho, right here it comes. This week, we now have feedback/questions relating to pound-for-pound, the Haney-Loma controversy, Danny Garcia, and ProBox TV,
Pound-for-Pound Revisited
Hello Paul,
Thanks for all of your laborious work and placing your opinions on the market even when the established boxing press has a vested curiosity in minimizing your voice.
Concerning your pound-for-pound article, I could not agree extra. I bear in mind one among Wladimir Klitschko’s methods was to lean on his opponents as a lot as potential to tire them out for later rounds. I’ve a sneaking suspicion that such a method would not work as properly for Naoya Inoue or Gervonta Davis.
I’ve a good bit of information of Olympic-style wrestling. Proper now, there’s an American heavyweight, Gable Steveson (Gold medalist in Tokyo in one of many coolest matches ever) who’s probably the most athletic heavyweight of all time. He can do issues no heavyweight has ever been in a position to do. However, many smaller guys have the identical elite stage, and even excessive stage, of athleticism. Does that diminish his unimaginable presents? Does that imply that pound-for-pound, he is a worse wrestler? No! In fact not.
I believe what pound-for-pound scores do is distract from occupied with greatness correctly. The boxing talent and motion that Tyson Fury has is unimaginable exactly as a result of he’s a large man. Through the use of pound-for-pound terminology, I believe it diminishes what a few of our nice fighters do and abstracts very actual concrete discussions we might have on approach and talent. Personally, I simply deal with which fighters are nice and use my very own biased and subjective strategy to consider who’s the best in the intervening time.
Simply my rambling ideas on an excellent matter.
Sustain the wonderful work and know that there are tons of people that actually recognize what you do.
Finest,
– Jeremiah
Hey Jeremiah.
Thanks for the sort phrases. It’s good to be reminded that even when self-important swamp-assed bloggers and the handy idiots within the mainstream media refuse to talk my title, my work DOES get on the market.
You’re proper, pound-for-pound is only a huge distraction. I’m not essentially in opposition to rankings, however any rankings based mostly on the subjective opinions of boxing media– a bunch of individuals stuffed with biases, blind spots, and odd agendas– is nugatory. This media of ours, sorely missing in self-awareness relating to their very own awfulness, at all times insists on placing their sloppy fingerprints on every thing. So, what we at all times get in these media rankings are lists of names put so as through consensus of non-expert specialists, based mostly on the whims, fancies, and sometimes defective opinions of the media members allowed into no matter clique is doing the rankings.
The one truthful and intellectually reliable method to do rankings, whether or not they be divisional or pound-for-pound, is to develop some kind of truthful formulaic methodology that ranks fighters on their precise advantage through accomplishment, exercise, and stage of opposition. The fingerprint of the media should be eliminated. None of this may be just like the opinion polls passing as rankings proper now. In a sport stuffed with sleight of hand and guided by a very inept and biased media, the one truthful rankings might be those who use the least quantity of human involvement potential.
And, by that commonplace, pound-for-pound can by no means be a factor as a result of there aren’t any actual, concrete standards by which fighters might be pretty ranked. Perhaps it could be higher to make rankings that fee fighters based mostly on exercise, success, and stage of opposition inside a sure time period. Then, that means, we’d get rankings that aren’t “legendary” and stained by the biases of the nerds compiling them.
However, then once more, if opinion was faraway from the equation, how would media members get their ego increase from being on an “skilled panel?”
Circling Again on Haney-Loma
I might prefer to circle again with you relating to the Haney-Loma aftermath. I perceive there’s corrupt judges in boxing. However theres no incentive on behalf of Prime Rank to lure the judges in favor of Haney. Haneys a free agent with all 4 belts in a division that’s Prime Rank’s bread and butter. What is the incentive for being corrupt in Haney’s favor?
The uproar is despicable and the response had me scratching my head questioning what did I miss! Did Loma outclass this man and I used to be fully oblivious to the actual fact? So I watched the combat once more with out the amount or anybody round. I could not discover 7 rounds for Haney or Loma. I discovered 5 rounds for every man and a pair of rounds that would’ve gone both means. Nevertheless it goes again to my unique concept. The bodywork, glove touching and jabbing gave the shut rounds to Haney.
Loma might be one of many greatest sore losers in boxing. He misplaced in opposition to Teo Lopez and blamed it on his shoulder. He misplaced an in depth combat final week and he went to the locker room in tears claiming theft When Andre Ward stopped Kovalev of their second combat, he was ringside claiming corruption and unhealthy referring. I imply this man will get a cross at simply being an all-around Diva.
Bernard Hopkins is asking for presidency regulation. Oscar De LA Hoya says that is the largest theft since he was robbed in opposition to Floyd. Paulie Malinaggi says “Loma deserves higher” as if he had the again of his neck stepped on. To not point out the Nevada State Athletic Commision is fining Haney 400K for shoving Loma. The underside line is that on the age of simply 24, Haney efficiently defended his undisputed standing twice. As soon as in Australia and as soon as in opposition to the so known as “Biggest Newbie of All Time.” Everybody else can kick rocks and go watch MMA or WWE if boxing is so corrupt!
– Nail Rahman
Hey Nail.
I do not suppose corruption in boxing is prefer it was once within the previous days. It’s institutionalized, constructed into the material of ordinary working process. No person advised the judges to cheat for the home fighter, no person needed to inform them to lean the way in which they did. For them, each Haney and Lomachenko have been home fighters as a result of no person on the time knew Haney’s standing when it got here to promotional corporations. Arum’s not going to inform them, “that is my man…give him the shut rounds.” As a brisker, youthful fighter with the 4 belts and all that future forward of him, it was secure to say that if each guys have been Prime Rank, the cash was behind Haney, so he acquired the good thing about the doubt.
Errors occur, biases in judging standards exist, however you need to admit that it is fairly damning that each one of those errors appear to occur to the good thing about the home fighter or the “cash” fighter. In all my time watching the game, I can rely on one hand– perhaps even two fingers– the instances a judging or scoring controversy did not work to the good thing about the home or cash fighter.
Once more, it’s not far-fetched in any respect. The judges all come from an inventory of pre-approved names (primarily pre-approved by the promoters). The pay/privilege/and many others. for the judges additionally comes from the identical promoters “deciding on” them through fee/sanctioning physique proxy. It’s an actual stretch to suppose that the judges wouldn’t be swayed into leaning, even subconsciously, in the direction of these making their high-profile gigs potential.
“In the event you suppose it is so corrupt, cease watching” is the flawed perspective to take. We now have to place stress on the powers that be to make the required reforms. One potential reply is to forestall promoters from signing fighters to long-term offers and make them bid on occasions on a combat by combat foundation. On this enterprise mannequin, there could be no “home” fighter and the promoter’s solely fear could be in making high quality fights that had a good, passable ending to ensure the followers stroll away not feeling swindled or cheated. The emphasis for the promoters could be on making good fights and never on defending their investments.
A number of this post-Haney combat uproar is coming from hardcore Lomachenko fan boys within the media and past. That is not my motivation. I picked Haney to win solidly. It doesn’t matter to me whether or not I like a fighter or not, I’m curious about equity. I hate to see followers speaking about levels of theft, like if a combat is shut, judges are allowed to get it flawed. As I stated earlier than, if “boxing logic have been utilized to the NBA, poor officiating could be extra tolerated in an in depth recreation as a result of, properly, it was shut anyway and shit occurs.” For me, if the flawed man is said the winner, that is a theft. And, whereas the combat was shut, there was a variety of odd logic from the judges’ facet that does not gel with what I noticed in there, particularly from Dave Moretti’s card. I’d be railing a couple of shitty choice whether or not it was Haney-Lomachenko or not. On this explicit case, there’s been further drama throughout due to Lomachenko’s “favourite son” standing in some quarters of the net Universo Pugilistico.
Danny Garcia, ProBox TV
Hello Paul,
A number of issues I might prefer to get your tackle:
1) I’ve at all times been a Danny Garcia fan however I gotta be trustworthy, I believe he peaked after the Matthysse combat and has been kind of “meh” ever since. The place does he go from right here? Retirement? Additionally, why on the planet would he even take into consideration getting within the ring with Erislandy Lara? I imply, it’s, actually, the worst potential match-up for him. Canelo had a horrible time with Lara and I’d say Canelo is stronger and fairly significantly better at every thing than Danny. Assist me perceive as a result of I can not get there alone.
2) I’ll have missed it, however I do not suppose I’ve seen you write something about ProBox TV. It appears that evidently the Founder/CEO, Gary Jonas, is throwing round slightly little bit of coin attempting to get it off the bottom and Paul Malignaggi appears to be enjoying a significant position of their productions. Is there a future for an inexpensive all-boxing app with low to mid-level fights?
Finest.
– Will
Hey Will.
1) I don’t suppose Danny Garcia’s head has been totally in boxing for awhile. Final I checked, his social media timelines have been stuffed with his assorted non-boxing facet gigs, like his style line and hip-hop endeavors. He actually hasn’t fought with any sense of urgency in a really very long time, though I get that he’s extra of a cool-headed counter-puncher {that a} fiery battler. However, nonetheless, I do get the sense that he’s not burning with boxing ardour anymore and may be preventing to pad the nest egg. I additionally don’t get the selection of Lara as an opponent, until Staff Garcia is relying on Lara being a shell of his former self (which could possibly be the case). Given the present realities of the middleweight division, it additionally may be simpler to seize at a Lara combat than attempt for one more title exterior of the PBC household.
2) I haven’t talked about it, however I do take pleasure in ProBoxTV and I watch as usually as potential. They’re what they are– low-to-mid-level fights that, for probably the most half, are well-booked and as aggressive as realistically potential. I believe there’s a spot for one thing like ProBoxTV, so long as they’re sensible with their financials and work to maintain the product entertaining. Sadly, the fact is that these lower-level reveals hardly ever make any kind of vital cash. For promoters, they’re thought-about extra of an funding in constructing their fighters’ model to allow them to flip a revenue afterward. It’s questionable whether or not one thing like this could exist by itself and switch sufficient of a revenue to remain afloat. I hope they do stick round.
I liken this to minor league baseball, which is quaint and enjoyable (and low-cost) compared to the massive league product. It received’t be main league high quality, however no person’s anticipating one of the best of one of the best. They’re simply anticipating to be entertained.
Received a query (or hate mail) for Magno’s Bulging Mail Sack? The most effective of one of the best will get included within the weekly mailbag phase proper right here at FightHype. Ship your stuff right here: paulmagno@theboxingtribune.com.
